Soft before, hard after
Winning parties campaign on goals and bring in the hard permitting tools after the vote: in our count of 41 post-election actions, 2 of 19 controversial ones had been clearly promised, against 14 of 22 routine ones. Quebec and BC are the next test, and they start from opposite places.
Also in French: Discret avant, dur après
Governments that won elections during the tariff war rarely promised the tools they used afterwards. We matched 41 actions that five winners took after their votes (Ottawa, Ontario, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland and Labrador, and Yukon) against the platforms they ran on. Of the 22 routine actions, 14 had been clearly promised. Of the 19 controversial ones, those that drew organized opposition, a lawsuit or a split vote, 2 had.1
Quebec and British Columbia elected new governments in October, and they are the next test. They start from opposite places.
| Quebec (Parti Québécois) | British Columbia (Conservatives) | |
|---|---|---|
| Elected | October 5, minority | October 24 |
| Fast-track tools in the platform | None; it praises public hearings | Deadlines in law, a 120-day approval process, one review aligned with Ottawa's, repeal of DRIPA |
| What would count as a hit | Any bill that fast-tracks projects or lets cabinet set other laws aside | A bill with powers the platform left out or kept vague: exemptions from other laws, approval by default, cuts to assessment or public comment, approval over a First Nation's objection |
| Not a hit | The promised pay freeze, a regulatory-relief office | The deadline law, the one-review law, DRIPA repeal |
| Window closes | About December 29 | About January 17 |
The count behind the pattern
The two controversial actions that had been promised were deals, not powers. Ontario's agreements with Alberta to study pipelines, rail and a deep-water port, and Newfoundland and Labrador's benefits deal with Equinor on the Bay du Nord oil project. Of the 13 that created new powers or tax breaks or reversed a rule, none had been clearly promised: 12 were missing from the platform or only hinted at, and one went against it (Newfoundland and Labrador dropped a promised Churchill Falls referendum for a vote in its legislature).1
Two of the largest came within two months of the vote. Ontario's special economic zones (Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act (Bill 5 (ON))), which let cabinet exempt chosen projects from provincial laws, and Ottawa's power to exempt national-interest projects from other federal laws (One Canadian Economy Act (incl. Building Canada Act) (C-5)):
Event · 2025-04-17 · document · CA-ONOntario introduces Bill 5, whose Special Economic Zones Act would let cabinet exempt 'trusted proponents' and designated projects in special economic zones from provincial laws, regulations and municipal by-laws
On 17 April 2025, Ontario's Minister of Energy and Mines, Stephen Lecce, introduced Bill 5, the Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, 2025, which passed first reading that day. Schedule 9 of the bill enacts the Special Economic Zones Act, 2025. Under it, cabinet (the Lieutenant Governor in Council) may designate special economic zones, and the minister may designate "trusted proponents" and designated projects. Cabinet may then, by regulation, exempt them from requirements under provincial Acts, regulations or other instruments, including municipal by-laws, as those requirements would apply in a zone, or modify how those provisions apply. The schedule also extinguishes certain causes of action. Schedule 10 enacts a Species Conservation Act, 2025 and repeals the Endangered Species Act, 2007. The bill received royal assent on 5 June 2025 (Statutes of Ontario 2025, chapter 4). The Progressive Conservatives' February 2025 election platform had promised that, within "regions of strategic importance" such as the Ring of Fire, "pre-approved project proponents that meet high operating, safety and environmental standards will be granted automatic approval to proceed with early works once they've met duty to consult obligations."
- Legislative Assembly of Ontario, “Bill 5, Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, 2025”, 2025-04-17.
- PC Party of Ontario, “PC Party of Ontario 2025 platform, 'Our Plan to Protect Ontario'”, 2025-02.
- Wikipedia, “Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act (Wikipedia)”.
Event · 2025-06-26 · action · CABill C-5, the One Canadian Economy Act, including the Building Canada Act for national-interest projects, receives Royal Assent
Bill C-5, the One Canadian Economy Act, received Royal Assent on 26 June 2025, less than three weeks after it was introduced on 6 June. It enacted two laws: the Free Trade and Labour Mobility in Canada Act, which removes federal barriers to trade and labour mobility between provinces, and the Building Canada Act, which came into force the same day. The Building Canada Act lets cabinet list projects it considers in the national interest; for those projects, the findings needed for federal approvals are deemed to be made in the project's favour, the minister can issue a single document that stands for the specified federal authorizations, and cabinet can by regulation exempt them from provisions of the federal laws listed in the Act. The government said a new Major Projects Office would lead the work.
- Parliament of Canada (LEGISinfo), “Bill C-5 (45-1): An Act to enact the Free Trade and Labour Mobility in Canada Act and the Building Canada Act”.
- Justice Laws (Canada), “Building Canada Act (S.C. 2025, c. 2, s. 5), full text”.
- Intergovernmental Affairs Secretariat (Government of Canada), “Legislation to build One Canadian Economy receives Royal Assent”, 2025-06-26.
This is our own count, and it has limits. One coder classified every action; a re-check of ten drawn at random agreed on eight. Some calls are close: Ontario's platform did mention pre-approved proponents, so we coded its zones law as hinted at, not absent. The gap holds when "controversial" is defined more strictly or more loosely. It is a way to read platforms; it does not show that anyone hid anything.
Claim · mechanismWinning parties rarely spelled out their controversial fast-track tools before the vote: in our own count of 41 post-election actions by five tariff-period winners, checked against their platforms, 2 of 19 controversial actions were clearly promised, against 14 of 22 routine ones. The rally widened what could be done after the vote. This is a way to read platforms, not proof of concealment, and it supports 'Ottawa opportunistic' only weakly.
Winning parties rarely spelled out their controversial fast-track tools before the vote: in our own count of 41 post-election actions by five tariff-period winners, checked against their platforms, 2 of 19 controversial actions were clearly promised, against 14 of 22 routine ones. The rally widened what could be done after the vote. This is a way to read platforms, not proof of concealment, and it supports 'Ottawa opportunistic' only weakly.
Spelling the tools out is not always fatal. In 2025 the federal Conservatives promised "one and done" approvals and lost; in Quebec, the one party that pledged to revive the lapsed fast-track Bill 5, the CAQ, was shut out. In BC this year, the party that put its tools in writing won.
Quebec: nothing promised, so any such bill counts
The Parti Québécois platform promises no fast-track power, and leans against them. Two readers worked separately through its Livre bleu on independence and its 2026–2034 environment plan with a fixed list of search terms. Neither found any fast-track or set-aside power clearly promised.23
The environment plan calls the tradition of the public-hearings office, the BAPE, "a precious heritage" (p. 9). The Livre bleu faults Ottawa's high-speed rail law for replacing public hearings on expropriation with written objections, and says Ottawa's fast-track law aims to ignore provincial powers (pp. 373, 367). The nearest promise is to "reduce the administrative obstacles that slow major municipal projects" (environment plan, p. 25). (Quotes from French sources are our translations.)
So any bill tabled by about December 29 that fast-tracks projects or lets cabinet set other laws aside is a hit. One limiting the BAPE's hearings would also reverse a stated position. Tabling is enough; a minority government needs opposition votes to pass anything, not to table it. A separate, longer test asks whether Quebec tables a law like the old Bill 5 by October 2027 (see Quebec votes).
Event · 2026-10-05 · action · CA-QCQuebec general election: the Parti Québécois wins 59 of 127 seats, short of a majority; the CAQ is shut out (preliminary results)
Quebec voters elected a new National Assembly on 5 October 2026. In Élections Québec's preliminary results, with all 20,704 polling stations counted, the Parti Québécois led in 59 of 127 ridings with 28.02% of the vote, followed by the Liberals (40 ridings, 24.22%), the Conservatives (19, 20.67%) and Québec solidaire (9, 12.43%); Premier Christine Fréchette's Coalition avenir Québec won no seat (13.35%), and Fréchette lost her own riding (CBC News). A majority requires 64 seats; CBC News projects that the PQ, led by Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, will form a minority government. Preliminary turnout was 66.89%. Results become official after the recount of votes.
- Élections Québec, “Résultats des élections générales provinciales 2026 (préliminaires, dépouillement terminé)”, 2026-10-06.
- Qc125, “Projection Qc125 pour le Québec, mise à jour du 28 septembre 2026”, 2026-09-28.
- CBC News, “Quebec election: Parti Québécois will form minority government, CBC News projects”, 2026-10-05.
The first moves point elsewhere. The party's list for its first 100 days put first a bill freezing the pay of members, ministers and the heads of the main Crown corporations, and a secretariat for "regulatory relief"; it named no permitting law.4 The cabinet was sworn in on October 21. The National Assembly first sits on November 17, so no bill could be tabled before then.5
Event · 2026-10-03 · statement · CA-QCPQ's 100-day priorities: a pay-freeze bill first and a secretariat for regulatory relief; no fast-track permitting law listed
Two days before the vote, the Parti Québécois published the first measures of a St-Pierre Plamondon government: a first bill freezing the pay of MNAs, ministers and the heads of the main Crown corporations until the budget is balanced; an emergency homelessness budget; removing tax on used goods; a fuel-tax cut worth 7 cents a litre; $100 million a year for food aid; a Secretariat for government efficiency and regulatory relief with a line-by-line review of programs and regulations and an audit of IT projects; lower immigration levels; and an Estates General on education in winter 2027 (Parti Québécois, 2026-10-03). The list does not mention reintroducing a fast-track permitting law like the CAQ's Bill 5, Churchill Falls or the referendum.
- Parti Québécois, “Paul St-Pierre Plamondon présente ses priorités pour les 100 premiers jours d'un gouvernement du Parti Québécois”, 2026-10-03.
Event · 2026-10-21 · action · CA-QCPaul St-Pierre Plamondon sworn in as Quebec premier with a 22-minister PQ cabinet, including a minister responsible for independence
The Parti Québécois government was sworn in on 21 October 2026: Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon and 22 ministers, nine women and 13 men, the smallest cabinet in 20 years (Global News). Portfolios from the premier's office release: Finance, Nicolas Marceau; Economic Development, Innovation and Energy, Stéphane Paquet; Natural Resources and Forests, Natalie Bisaillon; Environment, Jean Pellerin; Justice and Canadian Intergovernmental Affairs, Marie-Claude Sarrazin; deputy premier, Immigration and Integration, and minister responsible for Quebec's accession to independence, Catherine Gentilcore. The release and the coverage read say nothing on Hydro-Québec exports, mining or fast-tracking.
- Cabinet du premier ministre du Québec (via CNW), “Le premier ministre du Québec dévoile son Conseil des ministres”, 2026-10-21.
- Global News (via Yahoo News Canada), “PQ unveils smallest cabinet in 20 years”, 2026-10-21.
Quebec is the weaker half of the test. We had already read its platforms when we fixed the search terms; the BC platforms came out after.
BC: much was promised, so the bar is higher
The Conservatives put most of their fast-track agenda in writing. Their energy plan, released on September 28 and built into the platform, promises "a 120 Day Approval Process in legislation" and permitting aligned with Ottawa's one-year federal clock in Bill C-39 (Building Canada Strong Act (C-39)) (p. 5).6 The platform adds "one project, one review" approvals with fixed timelines (p. 20) and "Repeal DRIPA", BC's law on the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (BC) (SBC 2019, c. 44 (Bill 41, 2019))) (p. 46).7
Event · 2026-09-28 · document · CA-BCBC Conservatives' Energy Superpower Plan promises a 120-day approval process in law and permitting aligned with federal Bill C-39
On 28 September 2026 the Conservative Party of BC published its 'BC Energy Superpower Plan' ('Build More Faster'), which its platform later built in. It promises to 'Harmonize project permitting, approvals and consultation to align with Bill C-39 to ensure BC led projects are approved within the new federal one year time frame', 'directly supported by a 120 Day Approval Process in legislation', legal permit deadlines for natural gas, resource development corridors for pipelines and transmission, and to expedite the Ksi Lisims LNG project to a final go-ahead (pages 5, 6 and 8). It names no power to exempt projects from other laws.
- Conservative Party of BC, “BC Energy Superpower Plan: Build More Faster (Conservative Party of BC)”, 2026-09-28.
Event · 2026-10-16 · document · CA-BCBC Conservative platform promises to legislate 'one project, one review' permitting with fixed timelines; it does not mention Bill 15
The Conservative Party of BC's 2026 platform, 'Lorne Doerkson's Plan for a Stronger BC' (file dated 16 October 2026), promises to 'Legislate permitting and approval certainty, with fixed timelines, "one project, one review" approvals, and quarterly reporting of progress on each project' (page 20) and to make BC 'the fastest place in North America to permit a mine and an LNG facility' (page 16). The platform does not mention Bill 15 (the Infrastructure Projects Act), which the party's MLAs voted against in May 2025, so it does not say whether a Conservative government would bring Bill 15 into force, amend it or repeal it.
- Conservative Party of BC, “Lorne Doerkson's Plan for a Stronger BC (Conservative Party of BC platform 2026)”, 2026-10-16.
A bill doing those things matches the platform and is not a hit. Two readers, working separately, coded what it left out or kept vague.
A hit by about January 17 is a tabled bill that lets cabinet exempt projects from other laws, approves permits by default when a deadline passes or clears whole corridors in advance, cuts environmental assessment or public comment, gives private mines or LNG plants a special approval track, lets proponents' own professionals sign off permits, or lets a project go ahead over a First Nation's objection. The platform's own line is "Faster decisions do not mean weaker rules" (p. 21).7
Switching on BC's existing fast-track law, Bill 15 (Infrastructure Projects Act (Bill 15 (BC))), takes only a cabinet order, not a bill, so it does not count here; it is the subject of a separate test (see Passed is not switched on).
Event · 2026-10-24 · action · CA-BCBritish Columbia general election: the Conservatives win, leading in 63 of 93 districts on the preliminary count
On 24 October 2026 British Columbia elected a Conservative government. On Elections BC's preliminary count (as of 25 October, 99.96% of ballot boxes reporting), the Conservative Party led in 63 of 93 electoral districts with 48.05% of the vote, the BC NDP in 28 with 37.37% and the BC Greens in 2 with 10.97%; preliminary turnout was 48.12%. Mail-in and absentee ballots are counted in the final count, which ends on 6 November 2026. At the start of the campaign, 15% of respondents to an Angus Reid Institute survey (22 to 24 September) named US tariffs, Donald Trump or the alcohol ban among their top issues, far behind the cost of living (59%) and health care (42%).
- Elections BC, “2026 Provincial General Election: Results by Party (initial count, preliminary)”, 2026-10-25.
- Liaison Strategies, “B.C.: NDP Leads Conservatives 41% to 36% as Election Begins”, 2026-09-23.
- Angus Reid Institute, “Ballot Backlash: BC Conservatives open 8-point lead after snap election call, but electorate far from locked in”, 2026-09-24.
The first statements name a pipeline and DRIPA. The day after the vote, premier-designate Lorne Doerkson said he would work with Ottawa and Alberta on the Pacific Link oil pipeline, and that DRIPA could be repealed in the spring session. Results are to be certified on November 18, members sworn in on November 19 and the cabinet named on November 20; no fall sitting has been decided, though Doerkson has not ruled out a short one.8910
Event · 2026-10-25 · statement · CA-BCBC premier-designate Doerkson sets out priorities: advance Pacific Link with Carney and Smith, repeal DRIPA, a tax cut and a review of the province's finances; swearing-in after certified results expected 18 November
The day after the Conservatives' 24 October 2026 election win, BC premier-designate Lorne Doerkson said he would work with Prime Minister Carney and Alberta Premier Danielle Smith to advance the Pacific Link oil pipeline, calling resources 'the strongest hand that British Columbia hold'; repeal the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, which he said 'has caused more problems to date than I think potentially anything else', adding it could be repealed in the spring session; raise the basic personal exemption to $32,000; and order an independent review of provincial finances ($14 billion deficit). The swearing-in follows certification of the results, expected 18 November (The Canadian Press). The coverage read does not mention Bill 15.
- Yahoo Finance Canada (The Canadian Press), “B.C. Conservative's Lorne Doerkson sets out urgent priorities to govern”, 2026-10-25.
If the legislature does not sit before mid-January, the BC half cannot be scored. We will record it as not testable, not as a miss.
Reading the result either way
A hit in either province adds one case to the pattern. It would say that a new government, given a crisis, reached for a tool it had not asked voters for. Whether that matters for the build-out depends on what follows: a power on paper is not a power in use.
No hit in both would count against the pattern, for two different reasons. The PQ opposes the tools; the BC Conservatives campaigned on them. Either way, two winners in a row would not have followed the 41-action pattern, and we would say so and narrow the claim.
Pre-registered prediction P12 · open · registered 2026-09-27October platforms: "soft before, hard after"
Window: 2026-10-05 to 2027-01-17. What counts: The question: do governments leave controversial fast-track powers out of their election platforms, then bring them in soon after winning? We call this "soft before the vote, hard after". What counts as a hit: within about 85 days of the Quebec vote (October 5) or the BC vote (October 24), the new government tables a bill that fast-tracks projects or lets it set other laws aside, and those powers were missing from …
We publish the result after each window closes, whatever it is.
Who pays
The tools left out of platforms are mostly the ones that shorten the forum where opponents test a project. In our count, what made an action controversial was usually opposition from a First Nation, a municipality or an environmental group, or a court case. Those are the people who learn of a tool when the bill is tabled rather than when they vote. Who wins: proponents, who get faster decisions and more certainty.
A thought experiment: "Washington planned it"
One of the speculative explanations we track holds that US pressure was applied partly because Canada's response, building and exporting faster, serves US goals. We don't hold it; we test it because a lens we disagree with makes us look for evidence we would otherwise skip (see Why we test an explanation we don't believe).
On this test it predicts nothing different. Whether a provincial party campaigns softly and legislates hard is domestic politics. A hit would fit, weakly, the reading that Canadian governments use the crisis; it would say nothing about what Washington intended.
Claim · ottawaOttawa is opportunistic, following 'never waste a good crisis': it used the mandate and political cover of the tariff era to pass fast-track and tax tools. This judgment says nothing about Washington's intent.
Ottawa is opportunistic, following 'never waste a good crisis': it used the mandate and political cover of the tariff era to pass fast-track and tax tools. This judgment says nothing about Washington's intent.
Sources
- “Platform promises vs post-election actions: our coding of five tariff-period winners (41 actions, plus 2 control rows)”, 2026-09-27. ↩ ↩
- Parti Québécois, “Un Québec libre de ses choix : Livre bleu sur l'indépendance du Québec”, 2026-07. ↩
- Parti Québécois, “Le plan environnement du Parti Québécois 2026-2034 : prendre ses responsabilités, s'enrichir et améliorer notre qualité de vie”, 2026-08-12. ↩
- Parti Québécois, “Paul St-Pierre Plamondon présente ses priorités pour les 100 premiers jours d'un gouvernement du Parti Québécois”, 2026-10-03. ↩
- Assemblée nationale du Québec, “Travaux parlementaires : convocation de la première séance de la 44e législature”, 2026-11-05. ↩
- Conservative Party of BC, “BC Energy Superpower Plan: Build More Faster (Conservative Party of BC)”, 2026-09-28. ↩
- Conservative Party of BC, “Lorne Doerkson's Plan for a Stronger BC (Conservative Party of BC platform 2026)”, 2026-10-16. ↩ ↩
- Yahoo Finance Canada (The Canadian Press), “B.C. Conservative's Lorne Doerkson sets out urgent priorities to govern”, 2026-10-25. ↩
- Yahoo News (The Canadian Press), “Difficult and unpopular decisions ahead, B.C. premier-designate Lorne Doerkson says”, 2026-11-02. ↩
- Yahoo News (CBC News), “What's next as the B.C. Conservatives transition from opposition to government?”, 2026-11-04. ↩