EventAction
Bill C-39 passes second reading in the House 296-26 with Conservative support and goes to a legislative committee; clause-by-clause set for mid-November
The House of Commons passed Bill C-39 (Building Canada Strong Act) at second reading on 2026-10-08, vote 178, 296 yeas to 26 nays with 10 paired (LEGISinfo), and referred it to the Legislative Committee on Bill C-39. Conservatives voted with the Liberals to send it to committee; Poilievre called it 'weak, watered-down, long-delayed' and said his party would propose amendments. The NDP and Greens opposed. On 2026-10-09 the committee adopted a motion to begin clause-by-clause consideration in mid-November and invited ministers MacKinnon, Dabrusin, Hajdu and LeBlanc (Canadian Press). Not yet passed by the House; Senate stages and Royal Assent still ahead.
- Date
- Kind
- Legislation
- Where
- Canada
- Evidence
- Action: Something was done: a law switched on, a tariff imposed, money committed. How evidence is weighed
- Who
- Pierre Poilievre (spoke); House of Commons of Canada (acted)
Articles that cite this record
Sources
- Parliament of Canada (LEGISinfo), “LEGISinfo: C-39 (45-1), An Act respecting certain measures to strengthen the economy (Building Canada Strong Act)” (external site), . source record
- Lethbridge Herald (The Canadian Press), “Special House committee votes to push forward major projects bill” (external site), . source record
- Daily Commercial News (The Canadian Press), “Major government economic legislation C-39 clears first vote, heads to committee” (external site), . source record
Laws and agreements
How it bears on the outcome
| Explanation | Fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| C0 Ottawa as victim | Against weak | Ottawa pushing its own major-projects bill through the House is an active step, somewhat awkward for a picture of Ottawa as merely on the receiving end. |
| C1 Ottawa opportunistic | Fits weak | Advancing fast-track permitting legislation is consistent with Ottawa using the crisis; but the bill would be expected under other readings too, and it has not yet passed. |
| C2 Ottawa in no hurry | Neutral weak | Domestic permitting legislation fits equally with a patient stance on the trade talks; it says nothing about the pace of ending the crisis. |
| C3 Ottawa coordinating with Washington | Neutral weak | A domestic vote with cross-party support shows no sign of coordination with Washington either way. |
| O0 No meaningful speed-up | Against weak | A wide second-reading majority for a permitting bill makes a faster build-out somewhat more likely, which would be mildly surprising under no speed-up; the bill is not yet law. |
| O1 Faster, but the extra output goes mostly elsewhere | Fits weak | Consistent with a faster build-out; the bill says nothing about where extra output goes, so it fits O1 and O2 equally. |
| O2 Faster, and more volume reaches the US (this level or higher) | Fits weak | Consistent with a faster build-out; the bill says nothing about volume reaching the US, so it fits O1 and O2 equally. |
| O3 Locked-in preferential terms for the US | Neutral weak | No US supply guarantee, priority access or stake is part of this step. |
Logged against predictions
- P1: "No deal before the law" (a test of the foresight thought experiment) (logged 9 October 2026, logged only)
- P21: "The build-out laws outlast the campaign" (logged 9 October 2026, logged only)
- P6: Tariff-action test around the new laws (logged 9 October 2026, logged only)