Carnet 49An independent journal, with its receipts
Français

EventStatement

Trump at a Kansas rally on Alberta's referendum night: if Canada becomes the 51st state 'I will let you keep ice hockey' and 'O Canada'; Canada has 'been screwing us'

At a rally in Park City, Kansas, on Monday 19 October 2026, the night of Alberta's referendum, President Trump said of Canada: 'I do like their national anthem. And I promised them if they become a 51st state, which is actually what they should do -- I said I will let you keep ice hockey and I will let you keep your O Canada national anthem.' He went on: 'No, we're only kidding. We're having a good time. But they have been screwing us, really', and later said of Canada, 'I don't think they have a choice, if you want to know the truth.' The full transcript (Roll Call Factba.se) does not mention Alberta or the referendum. A statement only: no document, force posture or action.

Date
Kind
Statement
Where
United States
Evidence
Statement: Something was said. Weighted lowest: words cost less than actions. How evidence is weighed
Who
Donald Trump (spoke)

Articles that cite this record

Sources

Tested hypotheses: a thought experiment

Suppose Washington foresaw and wanted this. Would this event look any different than under the rival readings? This is a deliberately contrarian test, explained here, not the author’s belief. Judgments, not measurements.

Non-discriminating: this event fits the plain self-interest reading and the foresight reading equally. It does not tell them apart. What this means

ReadingFitWhy
I0a Accident
Tested hypothesis (intent)
Fits weakJoking rally remarks followed by 'only kidding' are consistent with impulse and domestic politics driving the rhetoric; rally talk is expected under most readings.
I0b Plain self-interest; Canada's response not considered
Tested hypothesis (intent)
Neutral weakThe complaint that Canada has been taking advantage of the US fits plain self-interest, but fits I1 and I2 equally; nothing bears on foresight of Canada's response.
I1 Foreseen and welcomed, not the reason
Tested hypothesis (intent)
Neutral weakNothing in the remarks bears on whether Canada's build-out response was foreseen or welcomed.
I2 Foreseen and wanted (this level or higher)
Tested hypothesis (intent)
Neutral weakThe remarks are about statehood and grievance, not about Canada permitting, building or exporting, so they do not separate I2 from the other intent readings.
I3 Worked-out plan with specific targets
Tested hypothesis (intent)
Neutral weakNo named projects, targets or timeline appear; a worked-out plan is not observed here.
R-annex Annexation
Rival reading
Fits weakRepeated 51st-state talk and 'I don't think they have a choice' are consistent with an annexation aim, but he called it a joke and no act accompanies it; statement only.
R-frag Fragmentation
Rival reading
Neutral weakThe transcript does not mention Alberta or the referendum, so it says nothing about breaking Canada up.
R-weaken Weaken-Canada rivals (annexation or fragmentation)
Rival reading
Fits weakStatehood rhetoric is consistent with a weaken-Canada aim through annexation, but as rally talk with no act it carries little weight.

Logged against predictions